Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login
Spongebob Season 4 Scorecard (Complete!) by MrEnter Spongebob Season 4 Scorecard (Complete!) by MrEnter
Okay, I got it figured out keeping track of which Spongebob episodes I've seen and which episode is worthy to review. Here's how it works with demonstration of my most known of the Seasonal Rot seasons.

*Unmarked: I haven't seen it, or I don't remember it.
*Atrocity: It's an Animated Atrocity, plain and simple.
*Debatable: This might be an Animated Atrocity. Take SquidBob Tentacle Pants. The episode has a pretty good plot and would be a "good episode" if it wasn't for that fucking flesh-colored blob at the end. Driven to Tears is one of the most moderate "Patrick's a Prick" episode.
*Good: The episode is tolerable. It doesn't really mean that it's "good" perse, but it does mean that it's watchable. Remember, that I may have some controversial picks. I've seen both Rule of Dumb and Wigstruck and worst lists, so if an episode you don't like is marked as "good" don't take it too seriously. It just means that I found some good in it.
Add a Comment:
269724 Featured By Owner Edited Oct 29, 2015  Hobbyist Interface Designer

Top 5:
5. Once Bitten: Good
4. Best Frenemies: Good
3. Dunces and Dragons: Great
2. Krusty Towers: Great
1. Have You Seen This Snail: Great

Honorable Mentions:

Shell of a Man: Good
The Lost Mattress: Good
Hocus Pocus: Good
Fear of a Krabby Patty: Good
That's No Lady: Good
Selling Out: Good
Patrick Smartpants: Good
Skill Crane: Good

Bottom 5:

5. The Gift of Gum: Bad
4. The Thing: Awful
3. Squid Wood: Awful
2. Good Neighbors: Painful
1. All That Glitters: Unbearable

Dishonorable Mentions:

Karate Island: Bad
Funny Pants: Bad
Best Day Ever: Bad
Deviantnate2004 Featured By Owner Oct 25, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
why the f is "rule of dumb" good?
magnifecent Featured By Owner Oct 25, 2015  New Deviant Student General Artist
cuz he notices his mistake at the end
magnifecent Featured By Owner Oct 22, 2015  New Deviant Student General Artist
Atrocities to good: none
Atrocities to meh: Best day ever
Meh to good: driven to tears
meh to atrocitie: squidbob tpants
CJO1234 Featured By Owner Sep 19, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
The final score is 27 good episodes, 2 debatables, and 9 animated atrocities.
MightyMewtron Featured By Owner Aug 30, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
the blob at the end of squidbob tentaclepants is actually removed in some airings on some networks, it's that creepy. 
269724 Featured By Owner Aug 22, 2015  Hobbyist Interface Designer
Top Five:

5. Hocus Pocus: Good
4. Once Bitten: Good
3. Shell of a Man: Good
2. Krusty Towers: Great
1. Have You Seen This Snail: Great

Bottom Five:

5. Funny Pants: Bad
4. The Thing: Awful
3. Squid Wood: Awful
2. All That Glitters: Painful
1. Good Neighbors: Painful

This may be where SpongeBob went wrong, but there are still quite a few good episodes in here. Unfortunately, it will get worse later.
Carvenamber Featured By Owner Aug 28, 2015  Student Filmographer
Good Neighboors isn't THAT bad.
magnifecent Featured By Owner Oct 22, 2015  New Deviant Student General Artist
lol yes it is
LuigiYoshiBros Featured By Owner Aug 16, 2015
Funny Pants - Meh
SquidBob Tentacle Pants - Good
Karate Island - Good
New Leaf - Meh
Bummer Vacation - Atrocity
Wigstruck - Atrocity
Squidtastic Voyage - Meh
That's No Lady - Meh
Hocus Pocus - Atrocity
Rule Of Dumb - Meh
The Gift Of Gum - Meh
Sablgardragonchrist Featured By Owner Aug 15, 2015  Hobbyist Artist
I think Born to be Wild or as I like to call it "Born to be Mild" was kinda good but not too bad.
Idyemyhairpink34 Featured By Owner Jun 28, 2015
Have you seen this snail is completely overrated 
sbfan101909 Featured By Owner May 23, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Why are there no scorecards for seasons 1 - 3 ? Are there just not enough you dislike for it to be worthwhile?
SploderianRich Featured By Owner May 24, 2015
Yeah, I'd believe so.
meta527ii Featured By Owner May 11, 2015
I gotta say, even though Rule of Dumb falls under reasonable catalyst, it was very satisfying when the townspeople stopped respecting Patrick.
Akus4ever Featured By Owner Apr 29, 2015
I agree with almost all of your choices for good, debatable and atrocity (I thought I'd be the only one who likes Rule of Dumb). I'd probably only change 2 or 3 of your choices like whale of a birthday (didn't like that one so much) and I think Best Day Ever is not as bad as everyone says it is. It's just a bit flawed (debatable)

But good scorecard
MaireadMalesco Featured By Owner Edited Apr 27, 2015  Student Filmographer
How is "Whale of a Birthday" good to you? You usually get offended when shows or movies make offensive jokes and morals about uncaring families. (ie. Chicken Little, Malcolm in the Middle, That's My Boy!, and Seashore Seashell Party)
magnifecent Featured By Owner Nov 8, 2015  New Deviant Student General Artist
he lost most of his money in a punishment
MaireadMalesco Featured By Owner Nov 8, 2015  Student Filmographer
I don't freaking care, being a terrible parent cannot be redeemed by the actions of his employee!
magnifecent Featured By Owner Nov 9, 2015  New Deviant Student General Artist
also there is a fucking word called an opinion
MaireadMalesco Featured By Owner Nov 9, 2015  Student Filmographer
Hey I know that word, don't be such a IDKC about it!
magnifecent Featured By Owner Nov 9, 2015  New Deviant Student General Artist
you're a dick too 
magnifecent Featured By Owner Nov 9, 2015  New Deviant Student General Artist
Yeah sure just completely copy pieguyrulz.
He lost his money in a punishment. HE GOT PUNISHED. 
bluepizza25 Featured By Owner Apr 25, 2015
Fear of A Krabby Patty: Great
Shell of A Man: Good
The Lost Mattress: Great
Krabs Vs. Plankton: Great
Have You Seen This Snail?: Awesome
Skill Crane: Great
Good Neighbors: I may have to watch it again.
Selling Out: Good
Funny Pants: Watchable
Dunces & Dragons: Awesome
Enemy In-Law: Watchable
Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture: Great
Patrick SmartPants: Awesome
SquidBob TentaclePants: Watchable
Krusty Towers: Awesome
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired!: Great (And now I'm thinking of Benson again! What is up with all these "you're fired" episodes? I know this one came before Benson, but still...)
Ghost Host: I may have to watch it again. I know it's good, but just how good? Awesome, Great, Good, or Watchable?
Chimps Ahoy: Awesome
Whale of A Birthday: Watchable
Karate Island: Watchable (Yeah, you know this isn't my #1 episode. I like it, but not as much as, say, Have You Seen This Snail?.)
All That Glitters: ScumBob (But a very mild one, some parts of the episode made me laugh. Other than that, annoying, meanspirited, and a, "Why am I wasting my time watching this?", kind of episode. Turbo Nick, you disappoint me.)
Wishing You Well: Again, I know it's good, but I don't know just how good, so I may need to rewatch it.
New Leaf: Good
Once Bitten: Great
Bummer Vacation: Rewatch! I know it's good, but how good is it?
Wigstruck: Watchable (But the part with SpongeBob shushing everyone at the theater cracked me up!)
Squidtastic Voyage: Meh
That's No Lady: Good (The near ending had me both laughing and making me say, "What the frig? This is so weird!" Brain Eraser from Regular Show had the same effect on me with its ending. Then again, Regular Show gets everything past the radar.)
The Thing: Good
Hocus Pocus: Good
Driven to Tears: Awesome
Rule of Dumb: Awesome
Born to Be Wild: Good, but how good? Rewatch time!
Best Frenemies (or, Friend or Foe?: The Prequel): Great
The Pink Purloiner: Awesome
Squid Wood: ScumBob (But again, very mild.)
Best Day Ever: Awesome (But not the best episode ever, at least to me.)
The Gift of Gum: Watchable
meta527ii Featured By Owner Apr 22, 2015
Hocus pocus is kind of a guilty pleasure for me.
Carvenamber Featured By Owner Apr 8, 2015  Student Filmographer
I really don't know what to make of Squidbob Tentaclepants. It's one of the most debatable animations I've ever seen.
crcoffin88redo Featured By Owner Apr 5, 2015
Saying an episode "might be an animated atrocity" is poor wording. For example, you said that Fiasco was kind of decent. If it's debatable, that can't be true. Saying it might be an animated atrocity is saying that it's definitely a bad episode (like One Bad Apple, Boast Busters, and Dragon Quest), but you aren't exactly sure whether you should consider it as bad as Rainbow Falls or Putting Your Hoof Down.
PhotonicFlame Featured By Owner Mar 24, 2015
Best of the season
-Fear of a Krabby Patty
-Shell of a Man
-Lost Mattress
-Have You Seen This Snail?
-Skill Crane
-Dunces and Dragons
-Krusty Towers
-Ghost Host
-Best Frienemies
Worst of the season
-Good Heighbors
-Funny Pants
-All That Glitters
-Squidtastic Voyage
-The Thing
-Squid Wood
-The Gift of Gum
Jediuser Featured By Owner Mar 21, 2015
top 5 episodes:
5. Fear of a Krabby Patty
4. Krabs vs. Plankton
3. Selling Out
2. Krusty Towers
1. Dunces and Dragons
bottom 5 episodes:
5. Funny Pants
4. The Thing
3. The Gift of Gum
2. Squid Wood
1. Good Neighbors
SploderianRich Featured By Owner May 9, 2015
I respect your opinion, but how is The Gift of Gum worse than The Thing?
Jediuser Featured By Owner May 9, 2015
Grossout, and Patrick seemed to care more about the gum than his friend's well-being.
SploderianRich Featured By Owner May 10, 2015
I thought it was pretty meh. Yes, the gum was gross, but imo, Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy 6 was a good episode which had grossout. The Gift of Gum's nothing terrible, but then again, it doesn't really stand out.
Jediuser Featured By Owner May 10, 2015
Grossout can be funny, but you can't overdo it. The Gift of Gum's whole plot revolved around a giant, chewed up wad of gum. 
SploderianRich Featured By Owner May 11, 2015
I thought the gum going all over SpongeBob's house was kinda "cool". But hey, I understand if you don't like the episode. And I agree! Selling Out was a great episode!
alexmarom11 Featured By Owner Mar 8, 2015
Skill Crane - Debetable
Patrick SmartPants - Debetable
Whale of a Birthday - Atrocity
Karate Island - Good
New Leaf - Atrocity
Once Bitten - Debetable
Driven to Tears - Atrocity
Best Frenemies - Debetable
The Best Day Ever - Debetable
jundy12376 Featured By Owner Mar 6, 2015
I honestly consider "Squidtastic Voyage" to be one of the best parodies of "Fantastic Voyage" I've ever seen.
Yoshiondiviantart Featured By Owner Mar 4, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I always considered season 4 to be just as good as the earlier seasons. Sure it had more bad episodes, and they were a lot worse than the bad stuff before, but something about the good episodes were just amazing.
BigMeatyClaws2000 Featured By Owner Jan 24, 2015

Karate Island- Meh
Squidtastic Voyage- Good
Best Day Ever- Good
The Gift of Gum- Good

Aaand that's all.
Carvenamber Featured By Owner Feb 21, 2015  Student Filmographer
I agree with you, except that I would switch around your opinions on the Gift of Gum and Karate Island.
SirMoody Featured By Owner Feb 15, 2015
Tuxedo-Guy2 Featured By Owner Jan 16, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
After the movie, I've been noticing a few themes with the newer SpongeBob seasons, including this one:

Season 4: Ren and Stimpy. Most of the episodes I've seen from this season, while good, mimicked Ren and Stimpy's humor rather closely, especially in the first half of the season.

Season 5: the "short" season. Most of these episodes seem to be really short for some reason...

Season 6: the strange season. What were these writers tacking on to?

Season 7: I have nothing for this one... mixed season.

Season 8: the vacation season. While the number is short, this season had a lot of vacation themes (golfing, a mini series on it, etc.)

Season 9: the B-movie season. Fitting, since this season began looking like a movie production in quality and screen orientation (at least my TV). Most episodes fit this theme, and while it did begin in Season 8 (Planet of the Jelly Fish and Attack of the 50 foot patty), this was where it was more prominent.
Jediuser Featured By Owner Mar 21, 2015
Actually, the episode is "The Krabby Patty That Ate Bikini Bottom"
Tuxedo-Guy2 Featured By Owner Mar 22, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
tstarr17 Featured By Owner Jan 7, 2015
Fear Of A Krabby Patty - Good
Shell Of A Man - Good
The Lost Mattress - Good
Krabs Vs. Plankton - Good
Have You Seen This Snail? - Good
Skill Crane - Good
Good Neighbors - Atrocity
Selling Out - Good
Funny Pants - Atrocity
Dunces and Dragons - Good
Enemy In-Law - Good
Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI - Good
Patrick Smartpants - Good
Squidbob Tentaclepants - Debatable
Krusty Towers - Good
Mrs. Puff You're Fired - Good
Ghost Host - Good
Chimps Ahoy - Debatable
Whale Of A Birthday - Debatable
Karate Island - Debatable
All That Glitters - Atrocity
Wishing You Well - Good
New Leaf - Debatable
Once Bitten - Good
Bummer Vacation - Good
Wigstruck - Atrocity
Squidtastic Voyage - Atrocity
That's No Lady - Good
The Thing - Atrocity
Hocus Pocus - Debatable
Driven To Tears - Good
Rule Of Dumb - Atrocity
Born To Be Wild - Good
Best Frenimes - Good
The Pink Purlioner - Good
Squid Wood - Atrocity
Best Day Ever - Debatable
The Gift Of Gum - Atrocity

Favorite Episodes - Krusty Towers, Dunces And Dragons, Mermaidman And BarnacleBoy VI
Most Hated - Good Neighbors, All That Glitters, The Thing
Jediuser Featured By Owner Dec 29, 2014
Top season 4 episodes: 
-Krabs vs Plankton
-Fear of a Krabby Patty
-Krusty Towers
-Selling Out
-Dunces and Dragons

Worst Season 4 episodes:
-Good Neighbors (The original Squidward torture porn)
-Funny Pants (Stupid plot, annoying as hell laughter)
-Squid Wood (A psychological Squidward torture porn? Interesting.)

I'll probably make my own deviations on modern Spongebob critiques.
SeanK9321 Featured By Owner Dec 27, 2014
My Opinions:
Fear of a Krabby Patty - Good
Shell Of A Man - good
The Lost Mattress - good
Krabs vs. Plankton - good
Have You Seen This Snail? - debatable (I don't understand why people like this, but to each their own)
Skill Crane - good
Good Neighbors - atrocity (Always hated this episode)
Selling Out - good
Funny Pants - atrocity
Dunces And Dragons - good
Enemy In-Law - good
Mermaidman And Barnacleboy 6 - good
Patrick Smartpants - good
Squidbob Tentacle Pants - debatable
Krusty Towers - good (favorite season 4 episode)
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired - good
Ghost Host - good
Chimps Ahoy - good 
Whale Of A Birthday - debatable
Karate Island - atrocity (a disgrace to martial arts)
All That Glitters - atrocity
Wishing You Well - good
New Leaf - debatable
Once Bitten - good
Bummer Vacation - good
Wigstruck - debatable
Squidtastic Voyage - atrocity
That's No Lady - good
The Thing - atrocity
Hocus Pocus - debatable
Driven To Tears - debatable
Rule Of Dumb - debatable
Born To Be Wild - good
Best Frenemies - good
The Pink Purloiner - good
Squid Wood - atrocity
Best Day Ever - debatable
The Gift Of Gum- atrocity

21 good, 9 debatable, 6 atrocities
This season was OK.
Idyemyhairpink34 Featured By Owner Dec 22, 2014
squidbob tencatlepants- good (Seroiusly the fleshy blob was only five seconds and is not even shown in most countries)
whale of a birthday- debatable 
wigsturck- atrocity 
driven to tears-good
best day ever- good
Aaran24 Featured By Owner Dec 5, 2014
My thoughts... may as well offer my 2 cents.
Fear of a Krabby Patty, Shell of a Man, The Lost Matress, Krabs vs. Plankton, Skill Crane, Selling Out, Enemy in Law, MM & BB: The Motion Picture, Patrick Smartpants, Squidbob Tentacle Pants, Krusty Towers, Mrs. Puff You're Fired, Chimps Ahoy, Once Bitten, Bummer Vacation, That's No Lady, Hocus Pocus, Driven To Tears, Rule of Dumb, Born to be Wild, Best Frenemies, and The Pink Purloiner - Good (22)

Good Neighbors, Funny Pants, Whale of a Birthday, All That Glitters, Squidtastic Voyage, The Thing, Squid Wood, Best Day Ever, and The Gift of Gum - Ranges from Bad to Awful (9)

Have you Seen This Snail and Dunces and Dragons - Excellent

Anything else is debatable. My opinion, mind you.
russellthedog Featured By Owner Dec 1, 2014  Hobbyist Filmographer

New Leaf - Debatable
Bummer Vacation - Debatable
Wigstruck - Atrocity
Rule of Sumb - Atrocity
Best Day Ever - Debatable
Add a Comment:


Submitted on
March 8, 2014
Image Size
362 KB


26,470 (16 today)
70 (who?)